Unveiling Long Island’s Finest: The Top 10 Burgers You Must Try

Written by on June 16, 2023

Long Island’s burger scene is a haven for those seeking the perfect blend of juicy patties, flavorful toppings, and artisanal buns. With a multitude of burger joints to choose from, we’ve narrowed down the options to present the crème de la crème. Prepare for a culinary adventure as we unveil the top 10 burgers on Long Island that will satisfy even the most discerning burger aficionados.

  1. All-American Burger (Massapequa)
    A timeless classic, All-American Burger has been serving up delicious burgers since 1963. The simplicity of their perfectly cooked patty, melted cheese, and a toasted bun encapsulates the essence of a true American burger experience.
  2. Gourmet Burger Bistro (Port Jefferson)
    Gourmet Burger Bistro in Port Jefferson is known for its upscale take on burgers. They offer a variety of gourmet toppings and sauces to elevate their juicy, flavorful patties. With a focus on quality ingredients and creative flavor combinations, this bistro is a must-visit for burger enthusiasts looking for a sophisticated twist.
  3. Black Label Burger (Westbury)
    With a focus on quality ingredients and culinary finesse, Black Label Burgers delivers an exceptional burger experience. The “Black Label Burger” with Vermont cheddar, applewood-smoked bacon, and their special sauce is a testament to their commitment to excellence.
  4. The Burger Spot (Garden City)
    A haven for burger lovers seeking innovative and delicious creations. They are known for their mouthwatering signature “Spot Burger” and the indulgent “Bourbon Street Burger.” With their commitment to culinary creativity and high-quality ingredients, this spot promises a memorable burger experience.
  5. Babylon Burger Bar (Babylon)
    Babylon Burger Bar in Babylon is a popular destination for burger aficionados. They offer a diverse menu with options to satisfy every palate. From classic cheeseburgers to unique creations like the “Mac Attack Burger,” this bar is dedicated to providing flavorful burgers in a vibrant and welcoming atmosphere.
  6. P.S. Burgers (Mineola)
    Delicious burgers focusing on on delivering classic, no-frills burgers that pack a punch in terms of taste. With their emphasis on fresh ingredients and perfectly cooked patties, this burger joint delivers a true taste of American nostalgia. It’s a great spot for those seeking a traditional burger experience.
  7. The Good Steer (Lake Grove)
    With a rich history dating back to 1957, The Good Steer is a beloved destination for burger enthusiasts. The “Steerburger” topped with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and their signature sauce delivers a classic and satisfying experience.
  8. Local Burger Co. (Bay Shore)
    A popular burger joint located in Bay Shore known for their commitment to using locally sourced, fresh ingredients to create delicious and unique burger creations.
  9. Gimmie Burger (Oyster Bay)
    Known known for its mouthwatering burgers, they pride themselves on using high-quality ingredients and cooking their burgers to perfection. With a variety of toppings and sauces to choose from, Gimmie Burger offers a customizable experience that caters to individual preferences.
  10. Burgerology (Huntington)
    Burgerology takes burger craftsmanship to new heights. Their menu caters to all dietary preferences, offering beef, chicken, turkey, and plant-based options. The “Burgerology Burger” with caramelized onions, bacon, and truffle aioli is a flavor explosion that will leave you craving more.

Long Island is a paradise for burger lovers, boasting a diverse range of burger joints that cater to every taste and preference. From the iconic All-American Burger to the gourmet offerings at Gourmet Burger Bistro, each establishment on this list provides a unique and unforgettable burger experience.

Current track